Three Paris police officers beat a Black music producer outside his studio, then wrote a report saying he had grabbed for a weapon. On Friday a Paris criminal court convicted all three and ruled that racism was an aggravating factor in the assault.
Michel Zecler, 47, was stopped on Nov. 21, 2020, over a missing face mask during France’s COVID-19 rules. The officers accused him of reaching for a weapon. A security camera recorded what happened instead. Zecler was left with head trauma, a split lip and scalp wounds, and a fully torn biceps tendon.
The court sentenced Aurélien Lapersonne, 29, Philippe Tondeux, 50, and Pierre Plantier, 37, to five years each, with three, three and a half, and four years suspended. Plantier will serve the remaining year with an ankle monitor.
The racism finding is the part that matters most, and it was not a given. Investigators had not included it in the charges. Zecler said he was called a “dirty Negro” during the beating, and France’s rights ombudswoman said four witnesses reported racist insults. The officers denied it. The court believed Zecler, finding his account consistent: he reported the slurs to a Black officer during the arrest, at the police station and to people close to him. It also held that the officers’ falsified report undermined their denials.
That report is the thread running through the case. Tondeux admitted at trial that without the video, “Mr. Zecler would have been convicted for facts he didn’t commit.” A false report is only caught when someone else holds the evidence, and Zecler had a camera.
All three officers apologized on Friday. Zecler’s lawyer said: “Justice has been done. It has restored a man’s dignity and allowed him to begin rebuilding himself.” A crowd applauded as Zecler left the courtroom.
Cases like this rarely reach a French criminal court, and a conviction that names racism and a falsified report is rarer still. It should not take a security camera and six years to get one.
Have your say