Mohamed Yusuf, a 51-year-old Somali American Uber driver from Blaine, Minnesota, is in critical condition at Hennepin Healthcare with broken ribs, a broken leg, spinal injuries, collapsed lungs and internal bleeding. A hospital spokesperson said he “continues to fight for his life, but his prognosis is poor,” as the Sahan Journal reported. The man charged with attempting to kill him has, according to the same outlet, posted bond and gone home.
Hennepin County prosecutors charged Samit Apurva Patel, 25, of Hopkins, with second-degree attempted murder and first-degree carjacking. Patel is presumed innocent. Charging documents say he was a passenger in Yusuf’s car early last Saturday and that Yusuf was choked with a seatbelt and run over with his own vehicle. Police found Yusuf in a ditch. Patel’s parents had called police for a wellness check, and Patel told officers he had “freaked out,” according to the charges.
The detail that has shaken Somali Minnesota is what Yusuf’s brother says he heard. Yusuf was on the phone with him when the passenger got in, and the brother says the passenger said he did not like the name Mohamed. Minutes later, the brother says, he heard Yusuf screaming in Somali that he was being choked and run over.
Hennepin County Attorney Mary Moriarty did not charge bias. “There is insufficient evidence to prove to a jury beyond reasonable doubt that a specific bias was the motivation for Mr. Patel’s actions,” she said, adding that this “does not diminish the pain that the family and the Somali community is feeling right now.” She also said: “It’s very difficult to get into somebody’s head and figure out what the motivations are.” Minnesota has no standalone hate crime statute. It enhances sentences when bias is proven, so the decision has real consequences for how long a conviction could carry.
Then came bail. Judge Paul Scoggin offered two options, according to MPR News: $1 million with no conditions, or $800,000 with restrictions including no alcohol. The Sahan Journal reports Patel posted the lower amount Wednesday and was released with electronic home monitoring. His next court date is Dec. 16.
For Somali Minnesotans, this did not land in a quiet year. Moriarty herself acknowledged that “the environment for our Somali neighbors in our state is absolutely frightening,” a reference to months of public attacks on the community, including from the president. More than 100 people gathered at the hospital Monday at a news conference hosted by the Minnesota chapter of the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR), which wants a hate crime investigation. A GoFundMe for Yusuf’s family had raised more than $400,000 by Tuesday morning. Strangers have done what the system has not: they have shown up.
A prosecutor is right not to charge what she cannot prove, and a defendant is entitled to a presumption of innocence. But a family can ask a fair question: if a man’s name was the last thing his passenger objected to before the violence, why is the accused home within days while the victim is still in surgery? The county should say plainly what its bias review covered, whether it is still open, and why $800,000 was judged enough to keep the community safe. The answers are due before Patel’s next hearing on Dec. 16.


Have your say