Evanston, Illinois, documented how it shut Black families out of good housing between 1919 and 1969, and then paid some of their descendants for it. The Trump Justice Department is now in federal court arguing that the payments are the discrimination.
The program was the first municipal reparations effort in the country. It offers Black residents who lived in Evanston in those years, or their direct descendants, up to $25,000 for home repairs, down payments or property costs. The city later added an option for direct cash. The money comes from a local tax on cannabis sales, and outlets report that between $5 million and $7 million has gone to hundreds of Black residents.
The suit, Flinn v. City of Evanston, was filed in 2024 by Judicial Watch, a conservative group, for six plaintiffs who are not Black and say they qualify as descendants of people who lived in the city in those decades. U.S. District Judge John Kness refused to dismiss it this spring. In October he allowed the Justice Department to join as a plaintiff.
The department says the program violates the Equal Protection Clause and the Fair Housing Act. Its filing says Evanston “has chosen to distribute substantial benefits to persons solely because of their race.” Harmeet Dhillon, the assistant attorney general for civil rights, said: “Simply handing out money based on race, however, is not the answer.”
Evanston has said it will move to dismiss the federal government’s complaint. A Justice Department spokesperson answered: “We will be opposing the motion to dismiss.” The city’s statement said it does not comment on pending litigation but will “vehemently defend any lawsuit.”
Who the harm fell on
The government’s strongest argument is that the city did not tie each payment to proof of an individual harm. The city’s defenders answer with the record: scholars documented the discriminatory housing practices in Evanston that the payments are meant to repair, and the people eligible are the ones those practices fell on.
There is also the question of who gets to claim injury here. The plaintiffs are not the residents who were shut out of Evanston’s housing market. Those residents and their descendants are the ones who received the checks, and a federal civil rights division is now working to take the checks back.
A ruling for the government would not stop at one suburb. Other cities weighing repair programs would read it as a warning, and the fight over reparations would be settled by people who sued over a grant rather than by those who were harmed.
Evanston has not yet filed its motion to dismiss, and no hearing date has been set. Black residents of the city have a program that exists and a federal government working to end it. The city should defend it to the end.


Have your say