Four Black teenagers were waiting for a ride home after football practice when armed Baltimore County police arrived. The threat was a bag of Cool Ranch Doritos their coach had given them. Now the four students are suing the school system, the police department, the principal and the company whose software called the chips a gun.
Taki Allen, Yui-Osa Ogbeide, Devon Thompson Jr. and Keith Winfield III filed the suit Tuesday in Baltimore County Circuit Court, a little over a year after the Oct. 20, 2025 confrontation outside Kenwood High School. The complaint calls it a “traumatic police takedown of four teenagers at their own school.” The students are represented by the Engel Law Firm, the Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights Under Law and Willkie Farr & Gallagher.
The suit describes officers arriving with guns drawn. It says three students were detained and a fourth was searched, and that they were forced to their knees on concrete. Officers found the chip bag in a nearby trash can.
The most serious allegation is about who made that happen. According to the suit, the school and police had cancelled the alert from Omnilert’s Gun Detect, an AI system wired into the district’s security cameras. It says Principal Catherine Smith overrode the cancellation and sent a screenshot to a school resource officer, who forwarded it to police. It also says the responding officers had a photo of Allen holding the chips and did not look at it before drawing their weapons, and that 10 officers who had correctly identified the chips never got word to the units on the way.
Omnilert has apologized. “What these four students went through on October 20, 2025 should not have happened, and we are truly sorry,” the company said. Baltimore County Public Schools and the county police declined to comment on the filing.
The students’ lawyers say this was no freak event. They say Baltimore County alone sees about 12 false positives a day from the system. The district rolled it out across 165 schools between fall 2023 and spring 2024. Each of those false alarms is a chance for armed officers to be sent toward children, and when the first call to police is a picture of a Black boy holding something, the cost of a machine’s error lands on him.
That is why this case is not a quirk of new technology. The software misread a snack, but people decided to keep the alert alive, and people at the scene never checked the photo that would have ended it. Black students have long been treated as threats first and children second, and an AI that guesses wrong a dozen times a day gives that habit a new excuse.
The students are not asking only for damages. They want better training and communication between schools and police, safety guardrails on the AI, and a pause on the system until those are in place. Given the number of false alerts their lawyers cite, the district should not need a court to order it.
Have your say