Starting Wednesday, organ procurement teams can raise donation with a patient’s family before the family has decided to withdraw life support. The change comes from the Organ Procurement and Transplantation Network, which runs the country’s transplant system, and it lands hardest on the people who wait longest: nearly 30% of the people waiting for a kidney are Black.
Until now, a bright line kept the two conversations apart. Doctors and families talked about whether to stop treatment. Only after that decision did the transplant team come in. The new rule lets the procurement organization start talking once end-of-life discussions are under way, as NPR reported. It also makes it easier for anyone in the room to pause a retrieval if something looks wrong, and it standardizes the tests used to determine death.
The network says the changes make the system safer and add donors. More than 109,000 Americans are waiting for a transplant, and about 12 of them die every day. Dr. Raymond Lynch of the Health Resources and Services Administration defended dropping the old separation: “Insisting on a bright line without focusing on what’s happening on either side of that line in time, that really just is a false sense of security.”
Dr. Lainie Ross, a bioethicist at the University of Rochester, called it “a really serious and really bad move.” She said: “I’m horrified to think that families will feel pressured.”
Both sides are talking about families in general. The waiting list is not general. According to OPTN figures as of Jan. 12, 2025, 27.8% of all transplant candidates were non-Hispanic Black, and 29.9% of kidney candidates were, in a country where Black people are about 14% of the population. Black Americans are about four times as likely as white Americans to develop kidney failure. White candidates outnumber Black candidates on the full list, but for kidneys the two groups wait in nearly equal numbers.
The question the rule leaves open is what it does to trust. Black patients already have reasons to doubt a medical system that has dismissed their pain and kept them off transplant lists for years. A request for an organ, made while a family is still weighing whether to keep treating someone they love, will be heard through that history. Nothing in the rule requires the network to publish donation consent or conversion rates by race, so no one outside it could tell if the change widens or narrows the gap.
It should. If the network wants the public to accept earlier asks, it owes families the data on who is being asked, who says yes and who ends up waiting. The rule takes effect Nov. 18, and a separate proposal on a controversial retrieval technique, normothermic regional perfusion, is open for public comment through Dec. 28.

Have your say