The family of Terence Crutcher will get a jury trial against the Tulsa police officer who shot him dead, a decade after he died. The U.S. Supreme Court declined on Oct. 5 to hear former officer Betty Shelby’s appeal, leaving in place a ruling that stripped her of qualified immunity. Trial is set for Feb. 8, 2027, in federal court in Oklahoma’s Northern District.
Crutcher, 40, was unarmed and Black. Shelby shot him on Sept. 16, 2016, during an encounter on a Tulsa street. A Tulsa County jury acquitted her of first-degree manslaughter in May 2017. The civil case his estate filed that year has spent the years since in the courts, and a district judge dismissed it on qualified immunity grounds, the doctrine that shields officers from lawsuits unless they broke law that was clearly established.
The Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals reversed that dismissal in March. “A police officer may not seize an unarmed, nondangerous suspect by shooting him dead,” the court wrote. Helicopter footage and dashcam video from an arriving officer both show Crutcher standing with his hands raised, the court noted. It said the evidence supports the estate’s claim that Shelby used unreasonable force.
The appeals court left in place the dismissal of the claims against the City of Tulsa, so Shelby alone faces the jury.
Shelby’s attorney, Scott Wood, argued to the Supreme Court that the Tenth Circuit relied on general excessive-force principles rather than precedent about her specific conduct. He has pointed to helicopter footage he says shows Crutcher reaching into his SUV. Shelby said at the time of the shooting that Crutcher kept putting his hands in his pockets, according to the court record as reported by Atlanta Black Star. Wood has said the case “has taken on both families.”
Crutcher’s twin sister, Dr. Tiffany Crutcher, has spent ten years as the family’s public voice. After the Supreme Court’s decision she called it “a breath of fresh air to know that the highest court in the land opened up the door for us to finally get our day in court.” At a press conference she called it “a great day for police accountability.”
For Black families who sue after a police killing, qualified immunity is often where the case ends before any juror hears it. Crutcher’s estate got past it only after the appeals court found the video evidence clear enough to send the question to a jury, and after the Supreme Court declined to disturb that finding.
Shelby can still settle before trial. If she does not, a jury will hear the case on Feb. 8.

Have your say