A Madison police officer shot Corey Ruiz three times on July 22, and on Thursday the Dane County district attorney said the officer will not be charged. Ruiz, 38, was Black. Officer Kiel Baitinger-Peterson is white.
District Attorney Ismael Ozanne concluded it was “reasonable for the officer to use deadly force when this person resisted officers, produced a knife, and was not affected by multiple attempts to use Tasers.” He added: “A person does not have to like and/or agree with the law, however I am sworn to apply the law to the facts at hand. The law applies equally to members of law enforcement and to those who are not.”
The decision rests on an account that no camera recorded. Madison officers do not wear body cameras. Police had been called about a man checking car doors, and four officers surrounded Ruiz on a bicycle in an intersection. Baitinger-Peterson fired from close range and hit Ruiz in the torso and the head.
The family’s lawyer, Ben Crump, points to bystander video. “In the video you see they tackle him, they tase him, they kick him and then the police officer executes him,” Crump said. “The video is the objective unbiased witness here.” He said the medical examiner told the family Ruiz would have survived if not for the shot to his head. “We don’t believe any of the shots were justified,” he said. “The kill shot to his head was not justified.”
Ruiz’s mother, Elsa Ruiz, said she has to live with it every day. “It hurts so bad not to have him here.” His brother, Adam Ruiz, put it more bluntly: “We’re destroyed. We won’t accept this.”
Ozanne’s finding is the official version, and it turns on the knife. That is the part the public cannot test for itself. With no body camera footage, the only recordings are bystanders’, the angle is whatever a passerby happened to have, and the officers’ accounts carry the rest.
It is not a new story on that ground. This is the third fatal police shooting in the same Madison neighborhood since 2012. Madison is only now moving on cameras: the department plans to equip every officer by the end of 2027, paid for with a $350,000 donation from a nonprofit. The city did not need to wait for a gift to decide that a man’s last minutes should be on tape.
Governor-elect David Crowley called the case “deeply troubling” and urged peaceful protest. Chief John Patterson has ordered an internal review, and Baitinger-Peterson and the other officers remain on paid leave. Complaints are already before the city’s Police and Fire Commission asking that Baitinger-Peterson be fired. Crump said the video “cries out for a civil rights lawsuit.”
A prosecutor’s finding that a killing was lawful ends the criminal case. It does not answer whether four officers, with Tasers in hand, had to end a stop over reports of someone checking car doors by killing a man. The Police and Fire Commission and a federal court can both ask that, and the family says it will put the question to the second.

Have your say