Tasia Fortune was 29 when she was found hanging from a tree behind a vacant house in Jackson, Mississippi, on Aug. 3. More than three months later, her mother says she still does not know how her daughter died, and on Tuesday a judge ruled that the murder case against one of the men charged is not strong enough to go forward.
The judge agreed at a preliminary hearing that there was not enough evidence against Earnest Lloyd Jr., 25, and sent the case back to Jackson police detectives for more investigation. Prosecutors had said it was not ready for a grand jury. The State Public Defender, Andre de Gruy, argued that the proper remedy is dismissal without prejudice, which would free Lloyd while police keep working and leave open the chance of refiling.
Police have charged three men in Fortune’s death: Lloyd, Eric Clark and Jarques Ratliff. A municipal judge earlier found probable cause to send Ratliff’s case to the grand jury. Police allege the hanging was staged after Fortune was killed. Lloyd has been charged, not convicted, and the ruling Tuesday means the state has not yet proved its case against him.
For Black Mississippians the image of a Black woman hanging from a tree is not a neutral one. Police Chief RaShall Brackney said as much: “We know we have a very sordid history around lynchings and racial terror.” Authorities have said they do not believe the killing was racially motivated, and Fortune’s mother said she thinks the killing was “something very personal, very personal.” That makes the stakes of a competent investigation plainer, not smaller: a family that feared a lynching was told it was something else, and is now watching the case come apart.
Fortune’s mother, Christey Spivey, did not spare the department. “I think it was handled sloppily,” she said. She pointed to the strain on the force: “There are only eight detectives, is what the chief told me, and 93 murders.”
Then came the part no family should have to say aloud. “I don’t even know how she died,” Spivey said. “Her death certificate says homicide by unspecified means, and I can’t even see the autopsy.” She said she is working on a petition to sue the Jackson Police Department over how the case was handled.
Jackson police have a defense that deserves a hearing: a department that small cannot work 93 homicides the way a family deserves. But that is an argument against the city’s choices, not for the case. A city that charges three people in a death the public watched, then needs a judge to tell it the evidence is not there, has not done its homework, and the people who pay for that are the family waiting for the truth and the men sitting in jail on charges that may not hold.
Jackson is a majority-Black city that has spent years short of money, water and officers. Fortune’s family should not have to sue to learn how she died. The city owes her mother the autopsy, and a case that survives its next hearing.
What happens next depends on what detectives bring back. Lloyd’s custody status and any refiled charge will be decided by prosecutors and the court.


Have your say