A member of Congress went to inspect an ICE detention center, and the Justice Department is prosecuting her for it. On Thursday the full U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit refused, 10 to 3, to rehear Rep. LaMonica McIver’s claim that the Constitution shields her from the case.
McIver, a New Jersey Democrat, is one of the Black women in office that civil rights groups said this week were being targeted by the Trump administration. The ruling leaves her with one realistic route left to avoid a trial: the Supreme Court.
The charges stem from May 2025, when McIver and other lawmakers visited Delaney Hall, the immigration detention center in Newark, on an oversight visit. Prosecutors allege she physically clashed with federal officers outside the building. She faces three assault counts and up to 17 years in prison. She is presumed innocent, and nothing the courts have decided so far addresses whether the allegations are true.
What the courts have decided is narrower. A divided three-judge panel ruled 2 to 1 on Aug. 26 that the Constitution’s Speech or Debate Clause, which protects lawmakers’ legislative acts, does not cover what she is accused of doing. The majority called her alleged actions outside the building “unambiguously non-legislative.” It rejected her immunity argument on two of the counts and sent the third back to the trial court. Thursday’s order lets that ruling stand.
McIver’s lawyers say the visit itself was the legislative work. Her attorney, Paul Fishman, said it is “too dangerous if the Departments of Justice and Homeland Security are able to thwart members of Congress from inspecting an ICE detention facility.” The defense says ICE officials obstructed the inspection and later lured lawmakers outside to arrest Newark Mayor Ras Baraka.
The dissent on the panel went further than immunity. Judge Thomas Ambro wrote that “the Constitution does not permit the Executive to wield its considerable discretion over criminal prosecutions in retaliation against disfavored legislators.” He said she deserved discovery into her claim that she was singled out for prosecution.
McIver, after the August ruling: “I will not fold to this administration. The administration will not stop me from doing my job or standing for what is right.”
The other side has a real argument, and it is not frivolous. No one, a sitting lawmaker included, is above the law, and the panel’s majority included a Trump appointee, Judge Stephanos Bibas, alongside a Biden appointee, Judge Cindy Chung. Whether she touched officers, and how, is a question for a jury.
But oversight of detention centers is the one tool Congress has to see what happens inside them, and it is now being tested in a courtroom against a Black congresswoman whose district includes Newark. The judges who wanted a rehearing were a minority of three. The question Ambro raised, whether this prosecution is retaliation, has not been answered by any court, and it should be before a jury is seated.
McIver’s team has said it is weighing every option. The next move is hers: a petition to the Supreme Court, or a trial date.

Have your say