New York City will not close Rikers Island by the date the law set. On Friday Mayor Zohran Mamdani laid out a plan to shut it by the end of 2032, five years after the Aug. 31, 2027 deadline, with $290 million through 2030 to cut the jail population by nearly 40%.
Those who wait longest are Black. The Data Collaborative for Justice found that by 2021 Black New Yorkers were jailed at 11.6 times the rate of white New Yorkers, and in 92% of the city’s zip codes Black residents were admitted to jail at higher rates than their share of the neighborhood. Another year of Rikers is another year of that.
The plan has two halves. The first is buildings: smaller borough jails in Brooklyn (2029), the Bronx and Queens (2031) and Manhattan (2032), plus a handful of medical and psychiatric facilities, for about 4,500 beds. More than 6,500 people are held now. The second is the one that decides whether the first works: getting people out.
The city wants no more than 5,500 people in jail when the Brooklyn facility opens, and no more than 4,100 by the end of 2032. It says clearing court delays alone could take roughly 800 people off the daily count, with about 1,700 more from diversion, supervised release and reentry services. About 85% of the people held are awaiting trial, and the average stay grew from 63 days in 2017 to 102 days in 2025. Defendants charged with murder wait an average of 690 days.
Most of the people in those cells have not been convicted of anything. The delay is a decision the courts and the city have made, and it falls hardest on the neighborhoods that supply the jail.
“It is time to finally close Rikers Island,” Mamdani said. “We have a legal and moral obligation to close Rikers.” City Council Speaker Julie Menin acknowledged that delays under previous administrations made a longer timeline necessary. The district attorneys said jointly that “we have a long way to go and many obstacles to overcome.”
The missed deadline is not Mamdani’s alone to answer for. The Adams administration opposed borough jails and federal oversight, and a federal judge has since appointed an outside remediation manager over the jails after finding conditions “abnormal and unacceptable.” About 2,450 cell doors still needed replacement as of October. The 2019 vote to close Rikers named Kalief Browder, who died by suicide after three years held there as a teenager.
The plan is honest about the arithmetic, and that is to its credit. But a closure date moved to 2032 is a promise people will serve time under. The measure to hold the city to is the population count: 5,500 in 2029, 4,100 in 2032. If those numbers do not fall on schedule, the new buildings will simply be where Black New Yorkers wait.

Have your say