The U.S. Supreme Court on Monday declined to hear the appeal of Nyra Miller-Fields, whose son, Ricky Cobb II, was shot dead by a Minnesota State Patrol trooper during a traffic stop for non-working taillights. The refusal leaves in place the dismissal of her lawsuit against the troopers. It ends the last court effort to hold anyone answerable for the death of a 33-year-old Black man.
Cobb was pulled over on Interstate 94 in Minneapolis on July 31, 2023. Troopers found an outstanding warrant and tried to arrest him. Body camera video shows Cobb driving away as Trooper Ryan Londregan, who had been trying to get him out of the car, held on. Londregan fired twice, and Cobb died.
Hennepin County Attorney Mary Moriarty’s office charged Londregan with murder and manslaughter. It later dropped the case, saying it could no longer prove the shooting was not authorized use of force after reviewing evidence from the defense. Gov. Tim Walz said he would have taken the case from her had she not dismissed it.
The family then went to civil court. The suit, filed in April 2024, argued the troopers made an unreasonable seizure and used “unnecessary, excessive, and deadly force.” A federal judge dismissed the claim against Londregan in October 2024 and found his use of force “objectively reasonable.” A second claim, against Trooper Brett Seide, was dismissed in January 2025. The Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals upheld the dismissal in July. The Supreme Court gave no hearing at all.
The troopers’ side has a real argument. The video shows Cobb driving off with an officer holding on to his car, and courts have given police wide room to decide in the moment. Londregan was exonerated by the State Patrol a year after the shooting.
But look at what the system did. A stop for a broken light ended in a killing, and it ended with a prosecutor’s retreat, then a judge’s finding, then a doctrine of immunity that shields officers from being sued unless an earlier case looks almost identical. No jury has heard the family’s case. Many Black drivers know the stop that begins with a taillight. Cobb’s mother never got the chance to ask a jury what it should cost.
The Minnesota Police and Peace Officers Association celebrated. “God Bless you Ryan. Thank you and your team for all the hard work and dedication Chris Madel!” it wrote, naming Londregan’s defense attorney.
Nothing left in the courts can change the result. What remains is the Legislature in St. Paul, which can write limits on when troopers may fire into a moving car and decide whether a family should be able to sue when a trooper kills their son over a taillight.

Have your say