Indiana voters have given judges the power to jail people before trial for crimes far beyond murder and treason. The state’s own numbers say the danger the change is meant to stop is rare: of nearly 96,000 defendants released after arrest in 2025, only 6.6% were rearrested before their case ended, according to figures Capital B reported.
Public Question 1 passed with 59% of the vote on Nov. 3 and took effect immediately. A judge can now deny bail if the person poses a “substantial risk to any other person or the community,” the evidence of guilt is strong, and the state shows by clear and convincing evidence that no release conditions would protect others. Before, Indiana guaranteed bail for nearly every charge.
The Black stake is in who decides. Capital B found that nearly two-thirds of Indiana’s Black voting-age population lives in counties where judges are appointed rather than elected. In Lake County, which includes Gary, the governor appoints judges and voters only get a retention vote every six years. Just two judges have ever been removed under that system. The power Indiana just handed to judges is one that many Black voters have little way to hold anyone accountable for using.
Supporters made a simple case. State Sen. Eric Koch said that in “more than half of the states, courts can order at least some dangerous suspects held without bail,” and that Indiana could not, as Capital B reported. Twenty-eight trial court judges backed the amendment. None of them serve Lake County.
The ACLU of Indiana answered that judges already had what they need. “They have a broad toolbox available to them already,” it said. The group notes that, according to the Vera Institute, seven in 10 people in Indiana jails are awaiting trial, and that people held before trial can lose jobs, homes and contact with their families. The Fort Wayne-Allen County NAACP branch said it feared the change would fall hardest on low-income defendants and people who do not live in the community.
Indiana was not alone. Tennessee’s Amendment 1 passed with 67.1% and lets judges deny bail to people accused of second-degree murder, terrorism, aggravated rape and other listed offenses, with a requirement that judges state their reasons on the record. Louisiana voters ended post-conviction bail for people convicted of aggravated offenses against minors. Ballotpedia tracked six statewide measures in 2026 that would raise penalties or restrict bail, and Stateline reported that voters approved all six.
The Marshall Project’s roundup of overlooked criminal justice results, published Saturday, shows the same election cut both ways: Democrats won three seats on Texas’s Court of Criminal Appeals, and jail construction projects did not fare well on election night.
Nobody disputes that a person who is truly dangerous can be held. The question is whether a state that sees 6.6% of released defendants rearrested needs a broader power to lock people up, and whether the people it will reach get any say in who holds it. Indiana has no data yet on how often judges will use it. The state should require every bail denial to be counted by race and county from the first week.
Have your say