Rhonda Grayson and Jeffrey Kennedy have already won. The Muscogee (Creek) Nation’s own Supreme Court ruled unanimously on July 23, 2025 that descendants of the people the Creek Nation enslaved are entitled to citizenship under the Treaty of 1866. Neither of them has a citizenship card.
So they went to federal court. Their suit, filed in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Oklahoma on July 23, 2026, names Principal Chief David Hill and the Nation’s Citizenship Board. Tribal officials filed motions to dismiss in October, the plaintiffs answered on Nov. 3, and the case now waits on a judge. The plaintiffs’ side says the outcome could affect more than 100,000 Black Creek descendants, and with them access to voting, housing, health care, education and business assistance.
The history is short and ugly. The 1866 treaty, signed after the Civil War, committed the Nation to treat its formerly enslaved people as citizens. The Citizenship Board denied Grayson and Kennedy anyway, in 2019, because they could not trace their ancestry to the “by blood” Dawes Roll and instead descended from people on the Creek Freedmen Roll. The Supreme Court found that practice violated the treaty. It also found that any “by blood” requirement in the Nation’s constitution is unlawful.
Then the order stalled. About a month after the ruling, Hill issued an executive order pausing enrollment cards for Creek Freedmen, saying he was upholding the Nation’s constitution. The tribal court closed the case in May 2026 without full implementation, according to the complaint. Hill’s side argues in court that the defendants are not the right ones to sue, that sovereign immunity applies, that they cannot issue the cards, and that a federal court has no jurisdiction.
“We won in the Nation’s highest court, but one year later we are still being treated as though the judgment never happened,” Grayson said when the suit was filed. Kennedy, vice chair of the Muscogee Creek Indian Freedmen Band, said: “Our children should inherit their citizenship, not this fight.”
The Nation has said that “matters of Muscogee Nation law and governance are to be addressed through the Nation’s own governmental institutions.” That argument deserves weight. Tribal sovereignty is real, and Indigenous nations have had too many outside hands on their governance. But this is not an outsider overruling the Nation. It is the Nation’s own highest court, applying a treaty the Nation signed.
When a government honors only the rulings it likes, the people left waiting are the ones the law was written to protect. In this case they are the descendants of people the Nation once enslaved, who have now won twice in the Nation’s own courts. The federal judge’s ruling on the motions to dismiss will say whether anyone can make the Nation comply. Citizenship cards, a vote and a seat at the table should not require a third court.

Have your say