Antwoina Carter, 26, called Cleveland police for help in the early hours of March 17, 2024. Minutes later, as she drove toward her mother’s house on Garfield Avenue in Glenville with a gunman firing from the car behind her, two officers standing in the street fired at her car too.
Now an Ohio appeals court has revived the lawsuit her mother filed over what Latrice Carter saw that morning. A Black woman who asked police for protection was met with gunfire from the people she was running from and from the officers she was running to.
Ohio’s 8th District Court of Appeals reversed a lower court’s dismissal of the suit against officers Dylan O’Donnell and Amanda Rock, as Police1 and News 5 Cleveland have reported. The court found that Ms. Carter’s complaint alleges reckless conduct, enough to go forward. It did not strip the officers of their immunity defenses, and the case has not been decided.
The basic facts are not in dispute. Officers had come to the home after a report of trouble, and were talking to Ms. Carter’s mother when shots rang out down the street. Video released by the city shows Antwoina Carter’s car coming toward them while being fired on from behind. O’Donnell and Rock believed the gunfire was coming from her car and opened fire on it. Cleveland police later found they had violated the department’s deadly-force policy by shooting without confirming a visible and immediate threat.
The punishment was a 15-day unpaid suspension for O’Donnell and 10 days for Rock. Neither faced criminal charges. Latrice Carter told News 5 the suspensions were too lenient.
Neither officer fired the shot that killed Antwoina Carter. Prosecutors said Christopher Stinson, a passenger in the pursuing car, fired 20 rounds and hit her once in the back. Stinson pleaded guilty to involuntary manslaughter and other charges and was sentenced to 27 to 32 and a half years. The driver, Trinity Ford, received 5 to 6 years.
The suit, filed in Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Court in July 2025, does not claim the officers’ bullets hit Antwoina Carter. It claims reckless conduct and negligent infliction of emotional distress, and seeks more than $25,000 in damages. Her mother’s cry on the video, “That’s my daughter! Y’all shooting at my daughter!”, is the injury at issue.
Attorney Tom Monah, who represents the family, said the department’s own discipline “just affirms everything we’ve been saying for over a year now, how things went down could not have been in line with public safety.”
When a Black woman calls 911, the officers who arrive should be the ones she can run toward. Cleveland has operated under a federal consent decree over excessive force since 2015, and its own finding here is that officers fired without seeing a threat. A suspension shorter than a month tells the next caller how seriously the department takes that.
The case now returns to the trial court, where a jury has been requested. A jury should hear what the department already found.

Have your say