Alfred Chestnut, Andrew Stewart and Ransom Watkins were 16 years old when Baltimore police arrested them for the 1983 killing of a classmate. They spent 36 years in prison for a murder they did not commit. Dawn Porter’s documentary about them, “When a Witness Recants,” reaches HBO Max today.
The victim was DeWitt Duckett, 14, shot in a hallway at Harlem Park Junior High School over a Georgetown jacket. Three Black boys from the same school were sent to prison for life for it. Director Porter has called their combined sentences the longest wrongful conviction in American history.
The film turns on Ron Bishop, who was also 14 in 1983. City prosecutors who later reviewed the case concluded that the lead detective, Donald Kincaid, had pressured the students who identified the three as the killers. Bishop was one of them. His recantation, brought through Baltimore’s Conviction Integrity Unit under then State’s Attorney Marilyn Mosby, led to the men’s exoneration in 2019. The film includes an arranged, on-camera meeting between Bishop and the men he helped convict. Ta-Nehisi Coates is an executive producer and appears on screen.
The men sued the Baltimore Police Department, alleging constitutional violations by Kincaid and two other former detectives, John Barrick and Bryn Joyce. In October 2023 the city’s spending board approved a $48 million settlement, $14.9 million for each man, with $3.3 million going to their attorneys. It is among the largest payouts of its kind in the city’s history.
That figure is the arithmetic of what happened: three boys, 108 years, one detective whose methods a city prosecutor’s office later found had corrupted the case. The check the city wrote is the part of the story that closes, and Baltimore’s taxpayers wrote it.
A 14-year-old with a detective across the table is not a free witness, and Bishop’s recantation shows what that pressure can produce. The cases that get re-examined are the ones where someone with power chooses to look. Baltimore’s unit did, and three men came home. Every city that convicted a Black teenager on a classmate’s word should have such an office, and use it.
The film premiered at the Sundance Film Festival on Jan. 27, where the three men received a standing ovation. Today it reaches the audience that matters more, which is anyone who still believes a confession or an identification is proof of anything on its own.

Have your say