A police officer in Headland, Alabama, was charged with causing his wife’s miscarriage. He never spent a day in prison. In the same county, women who tested positive for drugs while pregnant, most of whom gave birth to living babies, have been jailed, according to a ProPublica investigation.
The comparison lands hardest on Black women. Alabama leads the country in prosecuting pregnancy, and the group that tracks it, Pregnancy Justice, found that Black women were 60.3% of pregnancy-related arrests in the state between 2006 and June 2022. White women were 30.7%. Black Alabamians are roughly half that share of the population.
Robert Maddox Jr. was a rookie patrol officer when his wife told investigators in 2022 that he had choked her and punched her in the stomach while she was pregnant. She miscarried. He was first charged with murder, and a grand jury indicted him on manslaughter. In May, a Houston County judge dismissed the manslaughter charge after Maddox pleaded guilty to domestic violence. The sentence, as ProPublica reported it, was five years of probation, anger management classes and a $3,000 fine paid at $50 a month. He lost his job after the arrest. He was released on bond five weeks after it.
Now the other side of the ledger. ProPublica identified more than 40 pregnant women arrested in Houston County since 2009 under Alabama’s chemical endangerment law, which was passed in 2006 to go after meth labs. Prosecutors began applying it to pregnant women almost at once. Hospitals test women in labor, a positive result brings in child protective services and police, and nearly all the babies in these cases survived.
One former nurse with an addiction tested positive during labor in 2018 and was sentenced to 10 years, serving nearly 10 months. Another woman, arrested in 2024, spent four months in jail. Houston County has no drug court that could offer treatment in place of a cell.
District Attorney Russ Goodman told ProPublica: “During my term it is rare that we would sentence a defendant in these types of cases to a straight prison sentence.” Rare is not never, and the nearly 10 months served by the former nurse show it.
Lourdes Rivera, president of Pregnancy Justice, put the pattern plainly: “Law enforcement is using laws that were never intended to apply to pregnancy to investigate, arrest and punish women.” The group has counted 2,298 pregnancy-related arrests nationwide since 2006, concentrated in Alabama, Oklahoma and South Carolina, and says prosecutions appear to be rising since the Supreme Court overturned Roe.
ProPublica’s Houston County reporting does not break its cases down by race, so the county’s own disparity is not known. The statewide numbers are. A system that treats a pregnancy as a crime scene when the mother is poor, tested at a public hospital and defended by a public defender, and as a private family matter when the accused wears a badge, is not applying a fetal personhood law. It is choosing who it protects.
Alabama’s lawmakers have the power to end this by repealing the chemical endangerment statute as applied to pregnancy and funding treatment instead. Until they do, the next positive test in a delivery room in Houston County will be treated more harshly than a punch to a pregnant woman’s stomach.


Have your say