Montreal’s police chief fired seven officers on Nov. 2 over what he called discriminatory and racist behaviour. Twelve days later, none has been charged, their union is fighting the dismissals, and the people they are accused of mistreating are still waiting to learn whether anyone will answer in court.
Five of the seven worked out of Station 39 in Montreal-Nord, a north-end borough with a large Black population and the setting for the 2008 police killing of 18-year-old Fredy Villanueva. Two worked out of Station 21 downtown. Chief Fady Dagher said it was “a sad day but at the same time it was needed,” adding that it was necessary “to keep the trust with the police and the community.”
The allegations go beyond racist remarks. According to the Canadian Press, one officer is accused of cutting hair from racialized citizens as “trophies,” one of urinating on a homeless person, one of posing for mocking photos of arrested suspects, and one of interfering with a domestic violence investigation. All of it is now with Quebec’s Crown prosecution office, which will decide whether to lay criminal charges. Dagher has called the case “strong.” The officers are presumed innocent until a court says otherwise.
The Station 39 investigation became public in June, when the service disbanded a night patrol unit, suspended two officers and reassigned 14 others. Canadian Press reported at the time that some officers were accused of cutting dreadlocks from people they stopped. Six of the seven officers fired in November had already been suspended in the preceding months.
The fight is over the method
Dagher fired the officers administratively, by revoking their accreditation, rather than through the disciplinary route. The Fraternité des policiers et policières de Montréal says it will challenge exactly that. Union president Yves Francoeur said the dismissals were carried out “through a method that is totally unknown in our history” of labour relations, according to HR Reporter. The union is contesting the procedure rather than defending the conduct alleged.
That matters because a procedural win could put officers back on the payroll while the Crown is still deciding. Dagher has said the officers can seek reinstatement through the disciplinary committee, so the dismissals are not final.
Community groups welcomed the firings and said they are not enough. Afro Youth Summit leaders told the Canadian Press in June that what happened in Montreal-Nord “is not unique” and that they believe it is “endemic.” Montreal’s own research has long shown the stakes: a 2019 study found Black and Indigenous people were four to five times more likely to be stopped by police, and a 2023 follow-up concluded little had changed. Groups including RAPSIM have said the dismissals do not resolve what its director, Annie Savage, called “a fundamental problem in the SPVM that is found in many stations.” Some are calling for an independent public inquiry.
Firing seven people is the first thing a police chief can do, not the last. Black Montrealers have heard reform promises after every report since Villanueva. The test now is whether the Crown files charges, whether the dismissals survive the union’s challenge, and whether the SPVM’s action plan, promised for December, names the stations and the practices that let this go on for months before it was stopped.


Have your say