Austin Lumbard lost the race for mayor of Tustin, California, on Nov. 3. Two weeks later he put an item on the City Council agenda to fill seats on regional boards that, by tradition and state law, belong to the woman who beat him.
Letitia Clark, who will be the first Black woman to lead Tustin, won about 51.8% of the vote, according to Voice of OC. Lumbard withdrew the appointments hours before the council met Tuesday evening, after Clark and residents pushed back publicly.
The item would have named Councilman Ray Schnell to replace Lumbard on the Orange County Fire Authority board, created a Veterans Advisory Committee and filled a seat on the OC Mosquito and Vector Control board. In California’s general-law cities, the elected mayor makes those appointments, with council approval. Voice of OC reported that Lumbard’s move broke a practice nearly a century old.
Clark said the outgoing mayor was cutting the line. “Changing a long-standing practice before a new administration is sworn in brings about issues of fairness, respect for the voters and transparency,” she said. She said the move would “effectively deny the incoming mayor the opportunity to participate in decisions that will shape our city’s representation.”
Council member Lee Fink called it an “intolerable power grab by the candidate who just lost re-election.”
Lumbard said he pulled the item “in response to the substantial misinformation and negativity surrounding this item.” He had cited concern that unfilled vacancies would disrupt the boards. That is a case for filling the seats quickly under the new mayor, not for the old one to do it on his way out.
After the withdrawal, Clark said: “We are witnessing the power of the people and the effectiveness of the democratic process.”
Tustin had never elected a Black woman mayor, and the first attempt to shrink the job came before she was sworn in. Nothing was lost this time because residents showed up and said no. Clark takes office next month and plans to make her own appointments at the council’s second meeting in December. The Fire Authority seat is the one to watch.



Have your say