Eighteen congressional Democrats have given Dr. Mehmet Oz until Nov. 25 to explain why the $50 billion fund meant to keep rural hospitals open is being run with, in their words, “an alarming lack of public transparency.” The money is supposed to reach the places that lose hospitals first, and in the South those are disproportionately places where Black families live.
The lawmakers, who include Alabama Rep. Terri Sewell, Illinois Rep. Nikki Budzinski and Colorado Sen. Michael Bennet, sent the letter late Thursday to Oz, who runs the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS). They want to know how the agency is protecting “rural hospitals at greatest risk of closure” and whether the dollars reach hospitals or consulting firms. Agency officials did not respond to KFF Health News before its deadline.
The immediate trigger was a missed date. States expected their second-year awards by Oct. 31. On Oct. 30 at 4:05 p.m., CMS sent a mass email citing “an additional administrative process requirement” and gave no timeline. The awards came out Nov. 9. Each state’s total changed by less than 2% in most cases, though Alabama’s fell by $4.1 million. States now have until Nov. 30 to submit revised budgets.
The first year raised its own questions. States received between $147 million and $281 million, set by a federal scoring process, after about seven weeks to apply. KFF Health News found that states with Republican governors tended to get more of the competitive money and that Democratic-controlled states crowded the bottom quarter. Six states reported consultant contracts totaling more than $60 million.
Why it matters here: researchers at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill counted 334 rural hospital closures between 1990 and 2020. Of those, 175 were in the South, and closures happened disproportionately in counties with above-average Black populations. The same study found the median Black share of closure counties was higher in 2010 to 2020 than in earlier decades.
The danger has not passed. In a May report, the Southern Poverty Law Center found that 99 rural hospitals in Alabama, Florida, Georgia, Louisiana and Mississippi could be at risk of closing after the federal health cuts in the 2025 budget law. Thirty-four rural hospitals in the Deep South closed from 2005 to 2023, 10 of them in Alabama. Alabama got $203 million from the fund for 2026, and the SPLC says 82% of the state’s rural hospitals operate at a loss. Its verdict on the fund: “The appropriated $50 billion will do little to insulate rural communities and hospitals from the imminent damage.”
The administration’s case is that the program rewards states with the strongest plans, and CMS says it is working to resolve the delay. But a fund sold as a rescue should be able to say, in public, who got what and why. A county with one hospital cannot wait on an agency’s email. Oz owes Congress an answer by Nov. 25, and states owe CMS their budgets five days later.
Have your say