Memphis-Shelby County Schools earned the highest growth rating Tennessee gives for four straight years. For 2025-26 it earned the lowest.
The state’s Tennessee Value-Added Assessment System, known as TVAAS, measures how much students learn in a year compared with expected progress, not how high their scores are. Memphis scored a 5 from 2021-22 through 2024-25. This year the district scored a Level 1, as Chalkbeat Tennessee first reported from the state’s new public data portal. Most of the district’s students are Black.
The slide was widest in reading in grades 4 through 8, where growth declined significantly between 2024 and 2026. Five of six elementary and middle school grades earned a 1 in math growth, up from two the year before. Third graders fell behind expected growth in both math and literacy for the second year running. Science improved, and high school algebra and geometry beat the state’s growth expectations.
Bill White, the district’s research director, noted that Memphis is not alone: “MSCS is one of 53 school districts across Tennessee that received a Level 1 TVAAS rating this year.” He added: “Our focus remains on helping students make stronger, more consistent progress across grades and subjects.”
Dorsey Hopson, a former superintendent who now sits on the state-appointed oversight board for the district, called the data “sobering.” He said: “I would argue that a lot of it is a result of not making sure that we have a high-performing teacher in every classroom.”
Angela Whitelaw, the district’s chief of academics, pushed back on reading one score as the whole story: “Our academic data tell a story, and that story has several chapters; we have to read the entire book to understand the full story.”
Both things are true. A Level 1 across 53 districts is a statewide result, and the district had spent four years proving that Memphis children can grow faster than almost anyone’s. But a drop this steep, in the grades where children learn to read and do arithmetic, lands on children who have little room to lose a year. Third graders who miss growth two years in a row do not get that time back.
Memphis has also been under state pressure over its schools for years, and a single rating is exactly the kind of number that gets used to justify taking decisions away from a Black city. The answer should not be to argue with the number. It should be to ask what changed in classrooms, and to put money and experienced teachers where the growth fell furthest, before anyone in Nashville uses it as a reason to take more control.
The state’s portal lists the ratings for every Tennessee district and school.
Have your say