Houston’s city attorney has blocked an ordinance that would keep police from calling immigration agents over civil warrants, and the council members behind it say they wrote it to be bulletproof. “The way the ordinance is written, it’s unlawful,” City Attorney Arturo Michel told reporters Wednesday.
The ordinance would turn Mayor John Whitmire’s Nov. 6 executive order into city law. Whitmire’s order tells the Houston Police Department to contact Immigration and Customs Enforcement only if a suspect has an active criminal warrant or has been arrested for a new offense that could mean jail time. An order can be undone by the next mayor with a signature. An ordinance cannot.
The people who live with the difference include roughly 128,000 Black immigrants in the Houston area, about 10% of the region’s Black population, according to figures cited by the Houston Defender. For them, a traffic stop that stretches while an officer waits on ICE is not an abstraction. HPD’s most recent quarterly report counted 88 immigration-related ICE contacts between July and September. Average traffic-stop detentions reached 46 minutes by September.
Council members Alejandra Salinas, Edward Pollard and Tiffany Thomas filed the ordinance Monday under Proposition A, the charter provision that lets three members put an item forward without the mayor. They copied the mayor’s language word for word. “We did that on purpose to ensure we’d have no issues with codifying this into city law,” Pollard said after Michel’s ruling.
Michel’s answer is that an order and an ordinance are judged differently. He said he has to pass on the legality of an ordinance and cannot ignore that this one violates Senate Bill 4, the Texas law that bars local governments from limiting enforcement of federal immigration law. The mayor’s order stays in effect.
Whitmire defended the order as the best tool available. His office said adding provisions to the city ordinance would raise Houston’s risk of violating state law, and it called on new state leadership to revisit SB 4.
That risk is not hypothetical. Houston passed an ordinance limiting HPD’s ICE cooperation 12-5 in April. Gov. Greg Abbott then threatened to pull more than $110 million in public safety grants, and the council amended its own law 13-4 at Whitmire’s urging. Attorney General Ken Paxton sued the city over the original ordinance, and ABC13 reports he has renewed that litigation.
So Houston has a policy that protects people today and can vanish tomorrow, and a council that was pushed once to back down. The three members want the protection to outlast one mayor. That is the right instinct. A mayor who says he wants these limits and a city attorney who says they cannot be law have given Houston’s Black and immigrant residents a promise with an expiration date.
The ordinance still awaits a council vote, and Michel’s ruling means it cannot go forward as written.



Have your say