James O’Keefe walked into Minneapolis polling places last August using the names of real registered voters, some of them dead, according to prosecutors, and filmed it with hidden cameras. On Monday he stood in a Hennepin County courtroom to answer for it.
O’Keefe, 42, and Cam Higby, 26, appeared Nov. 16 before Judge Luis Bartolomei. Hennepin County Attorney Mary Moriarty’s office has charged both men with felony identity theft and unlawful voting. Prosecutors say they gave poll workers false names during the Aug. 11 primary, and that the voters whose identities they took never knew or agreed. Neither has entered a plea. The judge released both without bail and barred them from contacting the victims and the election judges named in the charging documents. Their next hearing is Jan. 13, 2027.
The videos, as the pair published them, showed them in religious dress and put-on accents, as reported by Courthouse News and others. O’Keefe has said the point was to expose the “sheer lunacy” of Minnesota’s vouching system, which lets a registered voter vouch for up to eight people who lack ID. The footage was posted online as proof that a Minneapolis election could be gamed.
The county attorney’s answer is in the charging papers. Moriarty said both men “stopped short of signing the oath we all sign before receiving our ballot.” She also said: “Elections are the bedrock of democracy and their protection is one of our highest priorities.”
O’Keefe’s lawyer, Christopher Madel, calls it a “First Amendment-protected investigation.” O’Keefe went further outside court: “This is now a landmark First Amendment case, and every American’s right to speak truth to power has been put on the line.”
The First Amendment protects a lot, but it does not usually cover claiming to be someone else at a polling place. Prosecutors allege the two did exactly that, with other people’s names.
Here is why it lands on our readers. Minneapolis is home to Black voters of every background, including one of the largest Somali communities in the country. A costume built on a caricature of Muslim immigrants, played for an online audience that has spent years casting Black and immigrant voters as suspects, is a ready-made rumor. Vouching is also a tool for people who have moved, who lack a driver’s licence or who are new citizens. Stories about “fraud” in that system tend to turn into arguments for stricter ID rules, and those rules fall hardest on Black voters. The only fraud documented here is the one prosecutors charged, and it was committed by the people who said they were exposing it.
The case will outlive the headlines. Cedrick Frazier, elected this month as Hennepin County’s first Black county attorney, takes over the office in January, and the trial is still ahead. Whether his office pushes it as hard as Moriarty’s did is a test of what the county means when it says voters’ names are not props.



Have your say