In 2016, seven Black students in Detroit sued the state of Michigan over schools that failed to teach them to read. The settlement, reached in 2020, put $94.4 million into the Detroit Public Schools Community District, and that money runs out at the end of this school year. The school board that must decide what replaces it was elected this month.
The district enrolls roughly 50,000 students, and by most counts about four in five are Black. The five people who won seats in the Nov. 3 election are Georgia Lemmons, LaMar Lemmons, Jameel Smith, Bessie Harris and Aliya Moore. They take office in January, as Chalkbeat Detroit and Michigan Public reported.
The settlement money paid for hundreds of academic interventionists who work with children in small groups, mostly in the early grades. Most of the new members told Chalkbeat that early literacy is their priority.
They also face a bill nobody has paid. An $8.7 million plan would return libraries to 89 schools, but keeping certified librarians in them costs an estimated $10 million to $12 million a year, according to Chalkbeat.
Then there are the buildings. Seventeen schools have low enrollment and high costs, and the district has already closed five, including Thurgood Marshall Elementary. Harris and the Lemmonses oppose more closures. Moore supports consolidation. Smith favors “boundary adjustments” and merging schools. With about four in five students Black, a closure here falls mostly on Black families.
The first test of the new majority is Superintendent Nikolai Vitti, whose contract runs to June 30, 2028. Moore has long called for his removal. The loudest critics who campaigned on firing him lost. Georgia Lemmons, who voted against his contract extension in 2020, said: “I want to see where we are now and what steps we need to take to move farther, because our children are, in my opinion, still not where they need to be.” Firing him would also require approval from the Detroit Financial Review Commission.
Test scores in the district have risen over the long term, but parents want faster progress, and voters told Michigan Public as much. One said: “They need a change when it comes to reading, a lot of students are really far behind where they have to be.”
Here is where we stand. The children who won this money did it in court, because the state would not do it on its own. A board that lets the interventionists go when the settlement ends, or closes a school to cover the gap, would be taking back what Black Detroit students already proved they were owed. The state settled that case and promised legislation, and it should be pressed to keep paying for reading help. The district has to adopt a new four-year strategic plan this year, and its goals for reading will be the first thing the new board puts its name to.

Have your say