Taki Allen was 16, waiting outside Kenwood High School for a ride home after football practice, eating a bag of Doritos. Eight Baltimore County police cars arrived. Officers ordered him and three other students to their knees, handcuffed them and searched them. There was no gun. Now the four teenagers are suing the company whose software said there was, the school system that used it and the officers who answered.
The Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights Under Law filed the 31-page complaint for Allen, Yui-Osa Ogebeide, Devon Thompson Jr. and Keith Winfield III, according to Courthouse News and TheGrio. It alleges violations of their federal and state constitutional rights, plus negligence and gross negligence, against Omnilert, which makes the Gun Detect system, Baltimore County Public Schools and the county police, along with individual officers.
The central allegation is that the false alarm was already over when the police came. School officials had recognized the mistake and canceled the alert, the suit says, but armed officers still showed up because the district had no working protocol to stop a police response once an alert was withdrawn. Allen, who is Black, was the student whose case drew national attention last October. Word In Black reported at the time that the principal re-escalated by contacting police rather than a parent.
“The police told my son this could have been a real problem,” Winfield’s mother said, according to the reporting on the suit. “No child in Baltimore County should face this kind of danger while waiting outside his own school for a ride home from his mother.”
What the state found
Maryland’s Office of the Inspector General for Education investigated and found the software “did not show any bias.” Investigators said the alert was triggered by the student’s hand position, an item that “extended slightly beyond the fingers” and was held near the hip. They also found that the principal did not see the cancellation message on a phone, that 15 people received the alert, and that attendance logs did not confirm the initial administrator training took place. They recommended reviewing who gets alerts and training staff twice a year.
That answers one question and leaves the one that matters. Software does not have to be biased to put a Black child at the end of a police gun. The code made a guess. People decided whether it ended in handcuffs, and the inspector general’s own findings show a district where the cancellation never reached the person who needed it.
Baltimore County pays Omnilert under a four-year, $2.6 million contract that runs through 2027. A second false alert at Parkville High School weeks later also brought an unnecessary police response, according to reporting on the suit.
A camera that can summon armed police to a campus, with no reliable way to recall them, is a risk the district bought and its students carried. The county and the company have yet to answer the complaint in court. Before that 2027 contract comes up, Baltimore County should be able to show that a canceled alert means no officers come.
Have your say