Eighteen states and Washington, D.C., have already promised to give their electoral votes to whoever wins the most votes nationwide. Together they hold 222 electoral votes. The National Popular Vote Interstate Compact takes effect at 270, and after the midterms the 48 it lacks are in view.
For Black voters, this is an old argument with a new deadline. At the Constitutional Convention in 1787, James Madison explained why a direct election of the president would not work for the South: Southern states “could have no influence in the election on the score of the Negroes.” The Electoral College, which let slave states count enslaved people toward their electors through the three-fifths clause, was the answer. Historians still debate how much slavery drove the design. Most agree it shaped it.
The modern version of the problem is geography. More than half of Black eligible voters, 57%, live in Southern states, Pew Research Center estimated in 2024, and Black voters are 37% of eligible voters in Mississippi, 33% in Georgia and 32% in Louisiana. Those states are not contested in a presidential race, so campaigns rarely visit them. The NAACP, which has backed a national popular vote since 2008, says only 17% of African Americans live in competitive states.
The compact would make a ballot cast in Jackson count the same as one cast in Phoenix. Michigan, Pennsylvania, Wisconsin and Nevada are now fully under Democratic control, Fox News reported, and Votebeat counts five swing states worth 61 electoral votes that could join: those four plus Arizona. Pennsylvania, Arizona and Michigan, plus either Wisconsin or Nevada, would get it past 270. Bills are expected early in 2027, and the deadline to take effect for the 2028 election is July 20, 2028.
The obstacles are real. A previous Democratic governor of Nevada vetoed the compact, saying it could force the state to award its votes to a candidate who lost there. Opponents such as Hans von Spakovsky of Advancing American Freedom argue it rewrites the Constitution without an amendment, and that Congress must approve it. Josh Douglas, an election law professor, told Votebeat: “If this does get enough states to put it into force, I think everyone agrees that it will end up in litigation.”
That fight would likely reach a Supreme Court that has already struck down the Voting Rights Act’s preclearance formula and let Louisiana lose a majority-Black district. Black voters should not assume it will rule their way.
They should still want the compact to pass. Under it, a Black voter in Mississippi would stop being a rounding error in a state the campaigns write off, and the voters who most reliably show up would finally be worth courting wherever they live. The test comes in statehouses in January, when the first bills are introduced.

Have your say