Before Gov. Gavin Newsom commuted every death sentence in California this month, 182 of the 561 people on the state’s death row were Black, 32.4%, according to the state corrections department’s count in March. Black Californians are about 6% of the state’s population. Now 29 district attorneys are asking the California Supreme Court to stop the clemency.
Newsom announced on Nov. 5 that he was converting 548 death sentences to life without parole. It is the largest mass clemency in U.S. history, and covers more than a quarter of the condemned people in the country. The district attorneys, who represent half of California’s 58 counties, filed their petition Monday, Nov. 16, alongside victims’ families and law enforcement groups. The Criminal Justice Legal Foundation, led by former Sacramento County District Attorney Anne Marie Schubert, is representing them.
Their argument is procedural. The petition says Newsom skipped the notice that state law requires to prosecutors and victims, and that he ignored victims’ right to be heard. “Only this Court can stop the Governor’s disregard of the law,” the petition says. Among the plaintiffs is Marc Klaas, whose 12-year-old daughter Polly was murdered in 1993. Families of 8-year-old Gabriel Fernandez and of firefighters killed in the 2006 Esperanza Fire are also named.
Newsom’s office answers that the notice rule does not apply when a governor acts on his own initiative, with no application from a prisoner. He has said his office will notify district attorneys and help with victim notification once the commutations go to the court. He acknowledged that those on death row caused “indescribable suffering to victims” and families, and wrote that “state-sanctioned killing is incompatible with California’s values.”
The case for his action rests on who was sentenced. A University of Miami study of California death sentences from 1987 to 2019 found that “the most likely person to be sentenced to death is a Black or Latino person who kills a white person.” Newsom wrote that “California is not immune from the invidious influence of racial bias in its application of the death penalty” and that “the nation’s capital punishment system is inextricably linked to the legacy of slavery and racial terror.”
The families suing have a real grievance: they want to be heard, and the notice question deserves an answer. But a notice dispute is a reason to hear them, not a reason to put 548 people back in line for execution, about a third of them Black, in a system where research found the race of the defendant and the victim shaped who was sentenced to die.
The state Supreme Court must also approve roughly 400 of the commutations, those for people with multiple felony convictions, which takes four of seven justices. The court has not said how or when it will review them. Newsom leaves office in January, and Gov.-elect Xavier Becerra has said he will extend the moratorium on executions.

Have your say