Tasia Fortune, 29, was found hanging from a tree behind a vacant house in Jackson, Mississippi, on Aug. 3. On Nov. 17, a Hinds County judge ruled there was not enough evidence to send one of the three men charged with her killing to trial, and the case went back to police detectives.
Judge Johnnie McDaniels made the finding at the preliminary hearing of Earnest Lloyd Jr., 25. The district attorney’s office told reporters it needs more evidence connecting him to the crime. Prosecutors had not presented the case to a grand jury. Lloyd’s lawyer, Nicholas Coleman, said he had not been able to speak to his client before the hearing, because Lloyd was in transit between facilities and did not appear. The status of the cases against the two other men charged was not made clear.
The stakes go past one courtroom. A Black woman hanged from a tree in Mississippi is an image the state has carried since the lynching era, and Fortune’s death was the third in less than a year in the state in which someone was found hanging from a tree, a fact that drew calls for federal involvement within days. Jackson Police Chief RaShall Brackney has said props were left at the scene as part of what police call the staging of the death, and she named the history herself: “We know we have a very sordid history around lynchings and racial terror across this nation and particularly around the South.”
Police and prosecutors have offered a different explanation of why Fortune died. A detective testified that she was killed over drugs, and that she fought her attackers. Those are allegations from investigators, and nothing has been proved in court.
Her mother, Christy Spivey, has been left with the least. “It’s hard. I don’t even know how she died,” she told Action News 5. “Her death certificate says homicide by unspecified means.” Brackney acknowledged at a news conference Wednesday that Spivey has been in touch with investigators several times and wants more information, and said, “we will share as much as possible.” The state forensic lab is still reviewing additional evidence, and the chief says she will bring the case back before a judge once investigators have what they need.
Three and a half months is long enough for a family to expect an autopsy explained to them, and for a prosecutor to know what a case rests on before a man is held. Jackson police have said the staging was deliberate and that the history matters. If so, a case that cannot yet hold up in a preliminary hearing is a failure the family should not have to carry. The next date to watch is the one Brackney has promised: the return to court, once the lab finishes.


Have your say