A federal judge on Friday refused to stop New York City from moving ahead with five city-run supermarkets that will sell staples at 30% below market price. Black New Yorkers, who report running short of food more often than white New Yorkers do, are the shoppers the plan was written for.
U.S. District Judge Jennifer Rochon, in Manhattan, denied a request from the National Supermarket Association, which says it represents 450 independent stores, along with City Fresh Market in Harlem and C-Town Supermarket in the Bronx. They had asked her to freeze the city’s search for operators while their antitrust suit proceeds. She found it unlikely that the city would use predatory “recoupment” pricing, meaning selling cheap now to drive rivals out and raise prices later, to make up for the revenue lost on the discounts.
The grocers are not villains in this story, and the ruling does not make them wrong to worry. Their complaint says the roughly $70 million in city capital money for the five sites gives the stores an advantage no independent owner can match. A second group, the Multicultural Business Coalition, has a class action in state court in Manhattan arguing that the plan violates the civil rights of smaller, minority-owned grocers who cannot match the discounts. Its lawyer, Richard Lawson of the America First Policy Institute, said the plaintiffs would keep going and “will be reviewing our options in light of the denied motion for preliminary injunction.”
Mayor Zohran Mamdani has called the plan central to making the city affordable. “I continue to be fully confident in both the legality and the importance of our initiative to deliver five city-run grocery stores,” he said when the state suit was filed. He has also noted that the city has more than 1,000 grocery stores, so five new ones are hardly a takeover.
That is the answer to the grocers, and it is a fair one. Five stores, one in each borough, cannot corner a market of 8.5 million people. The city has said it will hire a private operator and has prioritized so-called food deserts, where fresh food is scarce. East Harlem’s La Marqueta, on land the city already owns, was the first site named.
Who is likeliest to feel the difference is not in dispute. State Comptroller reports have found that Black and Hispanic adult New Yorkers are more likely than white adults to report food insufficiency. A 30% cut on milk, eggs, chicken and produce lands hardest in households that already skip meals or stretch them.
The paper’s view is that a public grocery is the right answer to a market that left whole neighborhoods without a decent supermarket, and that the city owes the independent owners a seat at the table, not a lawsuit. Rochon’s ruling covers only the request to pause the operator search. The antitrust case and the state class action are both still open.

Have your say