Chicago’s chief financial officer lasted three months. She quit after, in her words, being “admonished, frozen out, and bullied” for saying the mayor’s budget was less balanced than he claimed, and the largest item in dispute is the money the city pays for police abuse.
On Wednesday the City Council ordered an independent review of three years of city finances. It voted 45 to 5, ProPublica reported, and Mayor Brandon Johnson said he welcomed the review and would not veto it. For Black Chicago, the stakes are not abstract. The city’s police torture scandal alone, which involved more than 100 Black men, has cost taxpayers about $130 million in settlements and judgments, and the city is now preparing to borrow to cover the next round.
Ashlee Gabrysch resigned Friday. Johnson had said his $17.6 billion budget was 76% structurally balanced. She argued only 56% was, because police misconduct settlements and roughly $480 million in borrowing should not count as structural fixes, the Chicago Sun-Times reported. The $481 million is what Johnson has proposed borrowing to pay misconduct settlements in 2027 and 2028. In September, ProPublica noted, he had said the city would not borrow for these costs.
The mayor’s office says it “welcomes any independent audit” and that the city has “consistently received strong marks” in its annual financial reports. Finance Committee Chair Pat Dowell, who introduced the ordinance with 11 colleagues, pointed to the pattern: “In the wake of last week’s resignation of the city’s third CFO in a year, we find ourselves at a moment where every effort must be made to secure the public’s confidence in our city’s finances.”
The reviewers will have full access to city documents, and officials who refuse to cooperate face suspension or discharge. They are to look for “material or intentional misstatements” in what the city told investors, the council and the public. It is unclear whether the work will finish before the Dec. 29 budget deadline.
Wall Street is not waiting. S&P Global has put Chicago on CreditWatch and warned of a likely downgrade within 90 days, citing budget fights and the chance that the city will turn to “significant one-time measures” for 2027. The city carries about $55 billion in debt. A downgrade makes every future loan more expensive, and that cost lands in the budget lines that neighborhoods feel first: services, schools, repairs.
Gabrysch welcomed the review. “If this makes it easier for residents to see that Chicago actually is in a fairly dire fiscal situation where hard decisions … and shared sacrifices have to be made, that can be helpful,” she said.
She is right, and the mayor owes Chicagoans a straight answer. A progressive administration cannot treat the price of police abuse as a line to be borrowed away and counted as balance. Every dollar paid on a misconduct judgment is a dollar not spent on the housing, health and violence prevention the mayor ran on. The honest fix is fewer settlements, which means discipline that sticks. Johnson has until the Dec. 29 budget deadline to show the numbers.


Have your say